Topics›AI Drift Prevention and Review Culture›Charity Majors: Code Review Is Overrated, Non-Deterministic Systems Need More Engineering Discipline, Not Less
★Very HighAct: MediumFull content
Charity Majors: Code Review Is Overrated, Non-Deterministic Systems Need More Engineering Discipline, Not Less
The Pragmatic Engineer·August 12, 2026
New
Summary
Honeycomb's CTO argues code review is the least valuable thing humans add (humans are better at deciding what to build than reading code for bugs), that AI-written code needs trust to shift toward validation (tests, evals, conformance testing), and offers a personal rule: never send AI-written text to a human you haven't fully read yourself.
Why this signal
A genuinely contrarian, well-credentialed voice directly challenging Thomas Engineering's likely default assumption (more code review = more safety) — useful as a counterpoint to bring into the review-culture conversation rather than a single 'right answer.'
Original email
The Pragmatic Engineer · 8/12/2026
Stop being skeptical about AI for development with Charity Majors